Police committee backs proposed withdrawal of SAPS Amendment Bill to incorporate Madlanga recommendations

Parliament’s Portfolio Committee on Police has expressed strong support for a proposal to withdraw the South African Police Service (SAPS) Amendment Bill, saying the legislative process should accommodate recommendations from both the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry and Parliament’s Ad Hoc Committee.

The proposed withdrawal is intended to allow the recommendations to be considered before the Bill progresses further, in what the committee believes should be a more comprehensive approach to reforming the police service.

Committee chairperson Ian Cameron said some of the recommendations emerging from the two processes could have a direct bearing on provisions contained in the Bill.

He warned against pursuing police reforms in a piecemeal manner, arguing that changes to the legislation should be broad, inclusive and capable of addressing the systemic challenges facing SAPS.

The committee also raised concerns about the possibility of proceeding with the current Bill before the relevant recommendations are available.

According to Cameron, doing so could result in unnecessary expenditure if the legislation later has to be revisited to accommodate recommendations that could significantly affect its provisions.

He highlighted the public participation process as a particular concern, noting that the Bill requires extensive and costly consultation. The committee believes public representatives have a responsibility to protect public funds and avoid duplicating legislative work.

Despite supporting the proposed withdrawal, the committee stressed that the need for legislative reform within SAPS remains urgent.

It pointed to ongoing integrity management challenges within the police service, as well as areas where the current Bill may not be fully aligned with the Constitution and Constitutional Court judgments.

The committee’s position is that these issues require a more comprehensive legislative response capable of delivering meaningful and sustainable transformation.

The proposed withdrawal therefore does not signal that the need for the Bill has fallen away. Rather, the committee wants the legislative process to take account of the findings and recommendations of the two parallel processes before moving forward.

It remains important to establish whether a formal decision to withdraw the Bill has been taken, who must approve such a move and when a revised legislative process could begin.

Civic Desk SA will seek further clarification from Cameron on the next steps and the expected timeline for the proposed withdrawal.