T
KwaZulu-Natal tow-truck operator Clive Naicker has denied conspiring with police officers or offering money to have business rival Bevan Loftus killed, as the Madlanga Commission of Inquiry examined allegations surrounding the deaths of five men during a police operation in Durban in April 2023.
Naicker appeared before the Commission on Monday, where he was questioned about his relationship with Loftus, their business dealings and three telephone conversations between them.
His testimony follows earlier evidence from Loftus’s father, Gregory Loftus, an Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) investigator and a former police firearms expert, which raised serious questions about the circumstances surrounding the operation.
Five men killed during police operation
Bevan Loftus, Ryan Santos, Chase Fynn, Michigan Hippolyte and Sihle Zondi were shot dead on 1 April 2023 by members of the South African Police Service’s Cash-in-Transit Task Team at a property in Morningside, Durban.
Police maintained that officers had come under fire during the operation and returned fire.
However, subsequent testimony before the Commission has raised allegations that the operation may have been used to conceal an unlawful killing.
IPID investigator presents alleged financial trail
On 12 August 2026, IPID deputy director for investigations in KwaZulu-Natal Len Barnabas John testified about the directorate’s investigation into alleged criminality involving police task teams in the province.
John told the Commission that financial records raised concerns about payments allegedly received by Lieutenant-Colonel Deenadayalan Govender, a former commander of the KwaZulu-Natal Cash-in-Transit Task Team who later headed the Hawks’ provincial tracing team.
John alleged that Govender received more than R2.5 million in suspicious cash payments from a tow-truck company owner between August 2022 and December 2023.
He further alleged that more than R2.7 million was connected to the killing of Loftus.
The financial evidence formed part of broader allegations that relationships between tow-truck operators and police officers were being exploited by criminal networks.
Govender subsequently denied receiving money from Naicker and rejected allegations that he was involved in arranging the killing.
Father says he tried to stop his son’s killing
On 13 August 2026, Gregory Loftus told the Commission that he believed his son had been murdered by police under the guise of a legitimate operation and at the instance of Naicker, whom he described as a competitor in the towing industry.
One of the most significant aspects of his testimony was an urgent court application initiated on 31 March 2023, the day before his son’s death.
Gregory said he had deposed to an affidavit supporting an application seeking to prevent Govender and the SAPS from killing his son.
He told the Commission that Bevan had gone into hiding after receiving warnings that police officers intended to kill him.
Gregory also rejected allegations that his son was involved in drug dealing or the killing of other people, maintaining that he earned his living through legitimate towing operations.
He further described what he said was a pattern of police harassment that began in 2022.
Firearms expert questions police account
Retired SAPS captain and firearms expert Ashley Houston also testified on 13 August.
Houston examined aspects of the shooting and questioned the plausibility of the police account when compared with the physical evidence at the scene.
He raised concerns about the distribution of blood spatter and bullet impacts, saying these did not appear consistent with the account of an exchange of gunfire presented by the police team.
His evidence offered a forensic perspective on the circumstances of the five deaths, although it remains evidence for the Commission to assess and is not a finding of unlawful conduct.
Govender rejects allegations
Govender appeared before the Commission on 21 and 31 August 2026, denying allegations that he had received money from Naicker or authorised the killing of Loftus.
He maintained that his relationship with Naicker was work-related and denied having a personal relationship with the businessman.
He also disputed the allegation that he had commanded the operation in which Loftus and the other four men died.
His testimony included explanations for cash deposits into accounts held by him and his wife, which had been questioned by the Commission’s evidence leaders.
Naicker’s testimony brings the allegations into focus
On Monday, commissioners questioned Naicker about three telephone calls between him and Loftus.
Naicker maintained that he had never met Loftus personally and did not have a personal relationship with him.
He explained that one conversation concerned assistance for Loftus’s drivers, who were experiencing difficulties operating at accident scenes because they were not affiliated with a recognised towing association or institution.
A second call concerned the recovery of a vehicle following an accident on the N2 freeway.
The third conversation drew particular attention after Naicker confirmed that Loftus had mentioned that there was a price on his head, referring to the figure of 2.5.
Naicker said he was initially confused by the reference because similar terminology was used in the towing industry when discussing vehicle valuations.
He denied knowing about any arrangement to have Loftus killed, saying he had not discussed such a plan with anyone.
Commissioners also questioned the relationship between their businesses. Naicker initially maintained that they operated in different geographical areas but acknowledged that both companies could access a shared point on the N2 freeway and compete for work.
In his written statement to the Commission, Naicker denied conspiring with anyone to murder Loftus or offering a reward to police officers or other individuals to carry out the killing.
Investigation continues
The evidence surrounding Loftus’s death remains part of the Commission’s wider investigation into alleged criminal networks, corruption within law enforcement and the possible misuse of police structures in KwaZulu-Natal.
The Commission has not made findings on the allegations against Naicker, Govender or the other individuals implicated in the testimony.
Naicker’s evidence is expected to continue on Tuesday with parts of his testimony concerning his interactions with SAPS Crime Intelligence and criminal cases in which he is a witness have been reserved for in-camera proceedings.
Civic Desk SA will continue following the evidence as the Commission examines the circumstances surrounding the five deaths and the alleged links between the towing industry and law enforcement structures.


Leave a Reply